I still thought Andrew's performance was good, as well as Didi's. Shes adorable to me.

I think Tim stays because of VFTW. that black girl has GOT to go though.

no one really stands out to me though.

3/23/2010 11:38:19 PM

i'd say i love didi and crystal for the girls, and i love big mike, lee, and casey for the boys

3/23/2010 11:46:40 PM

many people dont like siobhan, which may keep her out of the top 2, but it seems like she is clearly the 2nd best singer.





did anyone else find it ironic that miley cyrus, who can not stay on key save for autotune, was the MENTOR for this week?

3/24/2010 12:16:45 AM

^yeah if i was some 23 year-old dude on AI, i doubt i could take advice from her.

3/24/2010 9:48:15 AM

i love Didi
i could listen to her all day. i thought her performance last night was great.

3/24/2010 2:54:38 PM

I went to high school with Didi in Knoxville. Absolutely one of the kindest and sweetest people you'll ever meet. We weren't close, but we talked every now and then. We all knew she was a great singer, but I'm actually suprised to see her in the Top 11. I'm really happy for her.

3/24/2010 3:39:02 PM

haha both the performer tonight would have been in the bottom half of this crappy season

3/24/2010 10:14:20 PM

i'm shocked katie was in the bottom 3. i would have picked the garcia kid to be down there with the other 2 clowns.

3/24/2010 10:17:08 PM

i cant believe this tim kid, he has got a horseshoe up his ass or something

3/24/2010 10:43:28 PM

they kicked off the right one.


although i wished they would have put miley cyrus in the bottom three... she sings like a deaf person talks.

3/24/2010 11:07:53 PM

can somebody please tell kara that "singer/songwriter" is not a music genre

[Edited on March 30, 2010 at 9:33 PM. Reason : garcia back! james and garcia are best so far]

3/30/2010 9:19:47 PM

my Top 4 picks are Big Mike, Lee, Didi, and Crystal*





*subject to change if they bomb next week

in all seriousness though, i think Big Mike and Crystal are Top 2

3/30/2010 11:37:47 PM

i was sad to say that i really didnt like Didi's performance last night but i lurve her anyways.

i really dont like the 2 16 year olds at all

3/31/2010 11:58:59 AM

^ agree

Lee rocked it out. He's like the white man counting crows.

3/31/2010 1:12:44 PM

the whole thing with Didi being about to cry and seacrest saying the song was meant for someone and they never really said who... and then showing her in the green room getting hugs was sad. it would be uber sad if she got sent home

3/31/2010 1:15:19 PM

it's a singing competition. not a who can have the saddest story competition

3/31/2010 1:17:04 PM

didi sucks ass.

that homeless looking chick and the douche-rock guy are my favorites.

3/31/2010 1:19:31 PM

IF THEY DONT SAVE DIDI I WILL BOYCOTT THIS SHOW


RAWR

3/31/2010 10:00:18 PM

GOD DAMNIT

3/31/2010 10:03:10 PM

there are so many people on there better than this chick. she's actually really annoying to me.

now if they'll just get rid of katie & that little country boy...

3/31/2010 10:08:23 PM

^^^are you serious? i couldn't stand didi. she was so dramatic and annoying. her voice was decent sometimes...but watching her was painful. glad she's gone.

^i agree on aaron kelly...he is so annoying. he isn't a bad signer...but i just hate him as a person/performer. so ready for tim to leave as well.

i'm pulling for lee all the way.

4/1/2010 6:27:02 AM

Quote :

"are you serious?"

because CAPS LOCK just screams serious

but she was one of my favorite girls, and i'm bummed to see her go

4/1/2010 8:39:27 AM

Didi was great. i loved her. i was very disappointed in some of her performances on the show but i thought her tone was amazing. when she did terrified...it was really good.

4/1/2010 10:45:39 AM

didi was terrible.

4/1/2010 10:55:36 AM

YOUR FACE IS TERRIBLE

4/1/2010 11:56:21 AM

MY OPINION OF YOUR OPINION IS THAT IT IS TERRIBLE

4/1/2010 12:01:55 PM

Big Mike!!!!


III

4/1/2010 9:53:42 PM

anrew garcia's performance of 'forever' by chris brown was awesome, seriously. I went back and listened to it a few times, then learned how to play it myself on the guitar. Great song

4/2/2010 11:43:57 PM

Fabio killed it tonight.

4/6/2010 9:28:06 PM

I wish I could negative vote for sioban and that little boy. Oh and miss early 90s too. Boooooooo

4/6/2010 11:18:03 PM

damnit

that would have been so hot if they sent him home

4/7/2010 10:23:15 PM

Personally I was glad to see them pull out the save. The weakest ones right now are Tim, Alex, Andrew, and maybe Katie. Big Mike just had a (kind of) bad week and Tim got lucky by having his first good week in ages.

Quote :

"i cant believe this tim kid, he has got a horseshoe up his ass or something"

Really--that and he's getting the 16 year old girl vote.

4/8/2010 1:14:44 AM

No thats not it at all.

He has the support of vote for the worst.com which puts out a HUGE amount of votes for him.

4/8/2010 2:23:46 AM

i knew they'd use the save as soon as ryan said "the results are shocking" during the first 5 minutes of the episode.

big mike won't win anyway, so it just postpones the inevitable. he is really annoying

4/8/2010 5:37:38 AM

Who should go: Andrew and Aaron

Who will go: Andrew and Mike

4/14/2010 8:35:46 AM

makes sense i guess. aaron prob deserved to go more than katie, but not by a longshot

4/14/2010 10:03:43 PM

Casey James is hot, but too hot...in a male model kind of way...

and I liked Andrew, but he got boring :/...He had potential!

I don't know how to spell her name, but she's the quirky girl with the short brown hair and blonde stripe, she has major diva tude...I love watching her facial expressions and last week when she ran back stage and yelled...awesomesauceness...

4/15/2010 12:20:53 AM

i thought Tim did the best overall last week
i was shocked that i liked it. i hardly ever listen to his performances

too bad Andrew peaked during Hollywood week

4/15/2010 7:47:16 PM

i haven't watched any AI this week, it's all on DVR and i'll watch it after work

so i dunno who got kicked off

but here's something i stumbled upon that i think is kinda cool. i don't agree with some of them though.

Top 20 Best Performances Ever

http://www.ew.com/ew/gallery/0,,20312226_20362239,00.html

4/22/2010 12:05:23 PM

^that was interesting...i definitely won't agree with having carrie underwood 13 and fantasia 1 in anything. it was cool to remember past performances though.

glad to see urban go home last night...can't wait to get rid of aaron kelly. anybody else notice how he has on a long sleeved shirt rolled up past his elbow every week?

does anyone not think that lee and crystal are the top 2 by a mile?

4/22/2010 12:19:23 PM

I don't think so. I feel Mike is best performer/singer by far. But everyone has their own taste/like. I pretty much think there are a few others that can sing, or have a nice voice; but I feel that Mike is most polished with the most talent and best vocals.

I am already awaiting his album release! Dude is going to be around for a long while (J-Hudson Style)



III

4/22/2010 12:30:18 PM

^^ i knew if i came back in here i'd see who got kicked off, haha. and yea, i totally agree with the Carrie/Fantasia comment. i didn't like a single song Fantasia did.

i agreed with Carrie Underwood, Daughtry, Kelly Clarkson, Blake Lewis, Adam Lambert (of course ), that Irish rocker chick, and Allison whatshername from last year. i think David Cook deserves to be in there, but for a different song. "Billie Jean" was good, but i thought his rendition of Mariah's "Always Be My Baby" was by far his best performance on the show. and Clay Aiken's best performance was "Bridge Over Troubled Waters" in the season finale.

^i think Mike, Lee, and Crystal are the Top 3. i would put Lee at #3, and i'm torn between Mike/Crystal for #1.

4/22/2010 12:33:57 PM

Cook's best performance was Eleanor Rigby.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dlsE97oPJYc

4/22/2010 12:43:30 PM

See, I think Eleanor Rigby was still a better performance than Billie Jean.

I guess it's all a matter of taste.

4/22/2010 12:44:33 PM

gahhh i hate this Aaron Kelly kid

he is annoying to look at and watch sing. I hate how he changes the lyrics of songs too because its "too adult."

God I hope he gets kicked off soon...good voice but he is annoying to watch.

4/27/2010 8:49:35 PM

Quote :

"anybody else notice how he has on a long sleeved shirt rolled up past his elbow every week?"

haha this week it was a jacket and it was only rolled to just below his elbow.

i put preshow points on his ass to go in my idol pool. no way he sticks around.

i cnat believe they are pimping his ass

4/27/2010 9:56:13 PM

watching some of those top 20 just help me remember how weak this year.

none of this years peeps hold a candle to carrie underwood or melinda doolittle

4/27/2010 10:28:43 PM

omg rascal flatts suck so bad live....well they suck in general.

4/28/2010 9:05:49 PM

rascal flatts is in tonite's bottom 3 fo sho

4/28/2010 9:09:24 PM

wow bottom 3

wtf yoda, force must really be with him, shit is ridiculous

[Edited on April 28, 2010 at 10:09 PM. Reason : hmmm wow]

4/28/2010 10:06:48 PM