^ that is the other david!! david hernandez i think his name is. i like both davids and the dred guy.

the girls i like are....brooke. the curly blonde girl. but i think i judge the girls more on appearance and whether or not i think i'd like them in real life. oops

3/4/2008 10:24:58 PM

yeah, thats his name. i like him too. i missed his performance tonight. what did he sing?
he did great last week.

im so bad with the names of the contestants but i know the girl you are talking about. i like the short haired black girl ... she lost her voice during the hollywood round but i think she is strong.

3/4/2008 10:32:45 PM

he sang celine dion. i thought it was good. judges weren't havin it. they said it was good but last week was better. i forget what celine dion song

3/4/2008 11:23:58 PM

he has a big voice but is it that big. i mean, ive seen people go down in flames trying to conquer her songs. but i do think he is gay so i can see why he would want to give it a try.

haha.

you said you like the guy with dreads, right...was he as hokey this week as last?

3/5/2008 9:01:12 AM

The dred guy was pretty good... although I can't remember what he sang.


Yeah, the gay extreme guy had a video where he was saying some shit about how santa raped your mother... really weird... reminded me of that guy/girl who did that LEAVE BRITNEY ALONE! speel... quite scary. I say he goes this week.

David H, I like, not sure how that whole dancing at a bar with mostly "male clientèle" will play out.

Of the ladies, I liike Syesha (short haired girl who lost her voice) and Brooke. I hate that "rocker" bitch. I can't understand what the fuck she's saying when she sings and she genuinely frightens me... more of a man than gay extreme guy.

3/5/2008 9:43:39 AM

i dont like that chick either but i do like the irish rocker girl
i think shes pretty good

3/5/2008 10:20:41 AM

the dred guy sang hallelujah by jeff buckley

3/5/2008 7:08:24 PM

^^ irish rocker girl (carly) is badass, big fan.

overall the girls had GREAT song choices, and most of them did pretty decently.

i think the dread guy is pretty weak, but he chose a great song with that version of hallelujah

3/5/2008 9:56:26 PM

my take on who goes tonight: Luke and Danny. Katy and Amanda.

3/6/2008 8:31:07 AM

my favorite is david cook

3/6/2008 8:41:54 AM

3/4 ain't so bad on my predictions.

3/7/2008 8:36:40 AM

which guy had on a red shirt last night?

3/7/2008 9:15:58 AM

^danny had a red jacket on and luke had a maroon t-shirt on. danny was the flaming guy.

i wasn't happy danny got kicked off, i enjoyed his antics. i like david cook and syesha the most.

3/7/2008 12:14:02 PM

danny could've been cool but he was way over board... if he just toned that shit down he might've been bearable.

3/7/2008 12:59:57 PM

im pissed they cut that asiah girl

she was one of my favorites. they should have cut the other black chick

the guys i'm alright with though

3/7/2008 4:50:27 PM

dude crushed that shit


one of my fav performances over the past few years

3/11/2008 7:24:34 PM

the guy with the dreads was boring. I liked the girl before him A LOT more. I mean she sang from her heart too and was told she was boring and this guy did something of the same pace and people love him

3/11/2008 7:38:03 PM

Elanor Rigby is my favorite mainstream Beatles song

he blew it


try again next year. that really sucked

[Edited on March 11, 2008 at 7:56 PM. Reason : ,]

3/11/2008 7:55:29 PM

that country chick is gone. i couldn't even watch it was so painful. that hillbilly rhythm just doesn't work on mainstream tv.

brooke white singing Let it Be was just awesome. her voice was a perfect match for that song

and ol chickizie tore it up too..don't know where he pulled that one from

[Edited on March 11, 2008 at 9:52 PM. Reason : ]

3/11/2008 9:51:39 PM

man the country girl was awful. that was painful to listen to.

i still <3 david cook.

david archuletta sucked.

3/12/2008 8:56:48 AM

I only watched the first half, and the irish chick was the only one worth watching.

3/12/2008 9:41:13 AM

i think david hernandez and the country girl are in trouble.


david cook did amazing with eleanor rigby, i thought. i'm looking to download that and his version of "hello"


also, the girl that did "let it be" absolutely captivated me. i know she's married, but man, i'm in love.

3/12/2008 1:42:47 PM

wow seriously? people actually care about this?

3/12/2008 1:45:17 PM

yeah, how dare people care about good entertainment and hearing some amazing artists sing

3/12/2008 2:10:56 PM

Quote :

"the irish chick was the only one worth watching."

With maybe a couple exceptions, the rest of them slaughtered the songs. Hooray for allowing Beatles songs into the catalog...

3/12/2008 2:36:33 PM

Chikezie gave one of the most entertaining performances I have ever seen. Paula described it starting out like "O Brother, Where Art Thou" which is the only correct thing she's ever said, ever. But it had that old American south "slave" rhythm to it with the bluegrass picking... then he turned it into rock... incredible.

Brooke... once again, she's something else.

David A. was actually painful to watch... and fortunately for him, the country girl completely ruined a great Beatles song. The judges were right to steer her in the country direction, but my God she took that waaaaaaay too far and probably procreated with a sibling in the process. Way over the top. I could see a fiddle in there to add a country flavor, but my God, that county fair performance was atrocious. She's gone, easily.

3/12/2008 2:54:53 PM

that nickelback no-talent low register-falsetto fake vocals eddie vedder style but twsited emo fag BULLSHIT hack who did the cover of Eleanor Rigby should be yanked off the show, made to get a haircut, and then forced to withstand 5 dudes fogprinting his stupid little faux rocker face with unshowered ballsacks for like 5 hours.

That was the worst bullshit I've ever heard, and the worst version of a song I've ever heard on this show. Granted, I watch American Idol because it's sort of a fascinating trainwreck....it's had its moments thats for sure, but that stuff I have ZERO tolerance for.

3/12/2008 3:33:00 PM

Quote :

"david cook did amazing with eleanor rigby, i thought. i'm looking to download that and his version of "hello" "

IMO, he absolutely butchered both songs. i think he's trash and needs to go immediately

3/12/2008 3:50:44 PM

Quote :

". then he turned it into rock... incredible."

it was good, but just a weeeee bit predictable


^^i'm sure you're quite proud of yourself for that stupid diatribe, but i thought the arrangement was badass (although i'm sure he stole it from someone else) and his performance was pretty decent. i'm not a big fan of his, but i can separate the person (who i dont like) from the performance(which i did)

3/12/2008 3:59:33 PM

i thought that arrangement was just par

lacked force, even with the "rocking out" part

3/12/2008 4:05:45 PM

in three weeks to come i predict these will be the next ones voted off:
-country chick (more than likely tonight)
-rocker chick
-Australian dude

you heard it here first.

3/12/2008 5:10:32 PM

Quote :

"^^i'm sure you're quite proud of yourself for that stupid diatribe, but i thought the arrangement was badass"

lol. ok guy. you would.

3/12/2008 5:17:18 PM

WHY THE FUCK IS THIS NOT BROADCAST IN HD (DIRECTV)

3/12/2008 8:00:13 PM

ok wtf is this woman thinking not showing off the twins? isnt that the only reason people liked her?

3/12/2008 8:42:08 PM

^^

i think the problem is

Quote :

"DIRECTV"

3/12/2008 8:49:41 PM

what! ok obvi i'm a day late. but why did david hernandez get kicked off. i liked him. its prob cause he was a male stripper. sad.

and wtf ruben????? sorry but you won american idol and did nothing.

also katherine mcphee is pretty. i like her. i didn't watch american idol until this season so, i never really heard her sing.

3/13/2008 8:03:47 PM

i thought she looked trashy...


and kristy lee cook better thank her lucky stars and better make good on her 80th second chance.

David H definitely did not deserve to get sent home over that raping of a great beatles song that cook did.

3/13/2008 8:19:50 PM

Well, the beatles are shit anyway, so like that really matters.

3/13/2008 11:13:40 PM

^^ haha at first i thought you said kristy lee cook is better and i was like WHATTTTTTTTT. but yea, she sucked and i hated her rendition of the song. a lot of the renditions ended up bad, but hers was just horrible. david hernandez was good (not his singing of the beatles, but other than that he's been good. i even thought his celine dion attempt went OK.) come on, america.

3/13/2008 11:26:13 PM

yea . . .

3/13/2008 11:29:20 PM

that dude was pretty generic and average

glad he's gone

3/14/2008 7:24:57 AM

For those of you that (for some reason) like David Cook. Read this: http://www.tmz.com/2008/03/12/did-david-cook-ripoff-eleanor-rigby/

Yes the whiny bag-of-emo-dicks ripped off an arrangement of a cover song from an equally cock-filled band.

Penis.

3/14/2008 10:15:12 AM

well i mean both sound like the beatles version to me...

3/14/2008 10:33:59 AM

Correct, neither deviate very far from the original. I'm not asking anyone to compare the songs to the original, compare them to each other, especially the piano line. That piano riff is not in the original arrangement.


Dude is a HACK.

[Edited on March 14, 2008 at 10:40 AM. Reason : ]

3/14/2008 10:38:19 AM

I hate the rocker chick... Kristy Lee Cook actually did something better... but not all that great still.

3/18/2008 7:31:54 PM

you've gotta be kidding me. did you see that iphone stuff? pathetic

3/18/2008 7:35:34 PM

I havent seen anything from this season minus auditions

I will tell you who will win after tonights viewing

3/18/2008 7:59:34 PM

i'm pulling for brooke... although her performance was less than great.

3/18/2008 8:01:00 PM

horrible version of blackbird

3/18/2008 8:20:12 PM

the brooke chick will do well
the black bird song girl, carly? will do well
the dreads guy, jason will do well
Syesha will do well

but the rocker guy David cook will win it all

i'll say it gets down to cook and jason for it all with carly in third

asian chick and the amanda girl
they gotta be in teh bottom again, asians gone

but the kristy girl sucks too


[Edited on March 18, 2008 at 8:55 PM. Reason : h]

3/18/2008 8:36:06 PM