rjrumfel All American 22986 Posts user info edit post |
I'm all in favor of taking the thing down, but that quote you put down is wrong. There were many Germans who fought for their country as a citizen, not as a Nazi. I don't think it is wrong for someone to look up to their German grandfather who fought and died for their country as a hero.
If said soldier was an SS officer? Sure, I wouldn't broadcast that, but just like many Germans fought not for the Nazi cause but for their country, so did many confederates die for their state, either forced into war by conscription, or by choice to fight for state, not for slavery. People in charge of the Confederacy most definitely wanted the institution to stick around, and tried to work in a set of laws to ensure slavery and inequality, but many people say, from the piedmont area of NC, couldn't have cared less about slavery. They were sold that yankees were going to come down and rape their families, so they fought. 6/25/2015 7:32:29 AM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
Nazi pride ok 6/25/2015 7:34:02 AM |
wahoowa All American 3288 Posts user info edit post |
^^ It just doesn't make sense to me why Southerners want to think Confederate soldiers were heroes. They were treasonous - the states that participated had sworn an allegiance to the US government by becoming states. The South also acted aggressively first with the attack on Sumter. The South fought for a terrible reason. The list goes on and on. Why the hell are Southerners proud of this? 6/25/2015 8:51:25 AM |
rjrumfel All American 22986 Posts user info edit post |
Ok maybe heroes is the wrong term here.
And no, I'm not glorifying Nazi's...did you read my post? Not every German was a Nazi. Just not every Confederate was a slave owning supremacist. Key word..CONSRIPTION. You fought or you died - either shot or hanged. Simple as that. Heroes? Maybe that's a stretch, but they did what they had to do.
There were conscription riots on both sides because people didn't want to fight.
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 9:24 AM. Reason : is/are] 6/25/2015 9:24:11 AM |
wahoowa All American 3288 Posts user info edit post |
^ I get your idea and I understand that many soldiers were forced into service, whether they had slaves or not (though many slaveowners were exempted from fighting if they had a certain number of slaves - 20 i think). What baffles me is that pride in the confederacy isn't necessarily derived from an ancestor that fought in the battle, but rather the romantic notion that the South was being bullied and had to defend itself from the "Northern aggression." Something about standing up to a government that was imposing on their state rights (because owning slaves was a God-given right). No idea why that is something to be proud of.
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 9:32 AM. Reason : a] 6/25/2015 9:31:50 AM |
afripino All American 11375 Posts user info edit post |
^^you're splitting hairs. let's look at the bigger picture. 6/25/2015 9:33:19 AM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
Are you stupid? If you fought in the war for the Nazi party you are a Nazi. If you fought in the war for the Confederacy you are a Confederate.
Those who fought for either of those two parties do not deserve to be honored. I'm sure there were Nazi's at Auschwitz that didn't want to gas and cremate jews, but they did. So should we just fly the Nazi flag because "some didn't have a choice".
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 9:38 AM. Reason : ,] 6/25/2015 9:34:13 AM |
Bullet All American 28263 Posts user info edit post |
Just a southern gentleman (and his supporters in the comments)
http://www.wral.com/confederate-flag-debate-a-way-of-life-in-rocky-mount-neighborhood/14736521/?comment_order=forward
6/25/2015 9:39:38 AM |
justinh524 Sprots Talk Mod 27740 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "They were treasonous - the states that participated had sworn an allegiance to the US government by becoming states." |
secession isn't treason. ]6/25/2015 9:41:39 AM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
A little arson would go a long way to fixing that problem.
^ It is when you lose.
] 6/25/2015 9:42:57 AM |
NyM410 J-E-T-S 50084 Posts user info edit post |
^^^ lol what an asshole. At least he doesn't give a fuck. 6/25/2015 10:17:09 AM |
wdprice3 BinaryBuffonary 45912 Posts user info edit post |
My personal reasoning for wanting the flag to come down from government entities is because of the outlandishly stupid arguments in support of the flag, whether it be in support of a government entity flying it, private companies pulling it from shelves (and other items with the flag), or private individuals flying it.
Why anyone would want to associate themselves with a flag that often flies for those believing, or have practiced, in hate, racism, the KKK, other white supremacy groups, and countless racist killers is beyond me. 6/25/2015 11:29:01 AM |
HUR All American 17732 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "And no, I'm not glorifying Nazi's...did you read my post? Not every German was a Nazi. Just not every Confederate was a slave owning supremacist. Key word..CONSRIPTION. You fought or you died - either shot or hanged. Simple as that. Heroes? Maybe that's a stretch, but they did what they had to do.
There were conscription riots on both sides because people didn't want to fight." |
Truth
Quote : | " get your idea and I understand that many soldiers were forced into service, whether they had slaves or not (though many slaveowners were exempted from fighting if they had a certain number of slaves - 20 i think). What baffles me is that pride in the confederacy isn't necessarily derived from an ancestor that fought in the battle, but rather the romantic notion that the South was being bullied and had to defend itself from the "Northern aggression."" |
Don't forget kids the North were the heroes who celebrated their victory over the South during Sherman's march by raping, pillaging, burning whole cities. This was followed by opportunistic Northern business owners sharing the spoils of war by taking "helping" the south recover by moving down and stuffing their pockets with profit from reconstruction (kinda like a 1800's version of Halliburton reconstructing Iraq)
Quote : | "Those who fought for either of those two parties do not deserve to be honored. " |
You are a fucking idiot. Comparing the confederacy to Nazi Germany is a complete strawman. There were plenty of Union states that had slaves and the majority of southerners who joined the confederate cause weren't pitching in because they wanted to protect large slave owning plantation owners. Plus many generals of the north could have been accused of war crimes had they been on the losing side.
You are so blinded by ZOMG they were the side that had slaves you don't see the big picture.
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 11:32 AM. Reason : a]6/25/2015 11:31:10 AM |
BobbyDigital Thots and Prayers 41777 Posts user info edit post |
take away this guy's confederate flags.
What changes about the guy?
Hint: now you don't know he's an inbred, racist dickfor.
I'm all for people waving/wearing/tattooing their rebel flags. To me, it's like a dunce cap. It's good to be able to identify them from a distance.
6/25/2015 11:35:20 AM |
jbrick83 All American 23447 Posts user info edit post |
I love how HUR shows up to post whenever there is an opportunity to remind everyone that he's a racist twat or when he does something really stupid and needs advice (like getting fired for creating safety hazards or getting towed for parking in a "Do not park here or you will get towed" area). 6/25/2015 11:36:09 AM |
HUR All American 17732 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "take away this guy's confederate flags.
What changes about the guy?
Hint: now you don't know he's an inbred, racist dickfor.
I'm all for people waving/wearing/tattooing their rebel flags. To me, it's like a dunce cap. It's good to be able to identify them from a distance.
" |
Truth!!!
Honestly if the goal is to improve race relations and decrease racism I think banning flying of the flag would be counter-productive in actually breeding hostility.
Quote : | "I love how HUR shows up to post whenever there is an opportunity to remind everyone that he's a racist twat or when he does something really stupid and needs advice (like getting fired for creating safety hazards or getting towed for parking in a "Do not park here or you will get towed" area)." |
I love how you get so worked up in chit-chat; it's exactly why i engineer my posts the way I do. I find it entertaining.6/25/2015 11:43:49 AM |
afripino All American 11375 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "To me, it's like a dunce cap. It's good to be able to identify them from a distance." |
That's what they say about brown skin color.6/25/2015 11:44:16 AM |
BobbyDigital Thots and Prayers 41777 Posts user info edit post |
hence why they have their dunce caps, whether it's a literal dunce cap/Klan Hood combo or the figurative rebel flag one.
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 11:48 AM. Reason : .] 6/25/2015 11:47:59 AM |
jbrick83 All American 23447 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "I love how you get so worked up in chit-chat; it's exactly why i engineer my posts the way I do. I find it entertaining. " |
I'm not worked up. I just find you entertaining....and dumb.6/25/2015 11:48:39 AM |
synapse play so hard 60929 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Comparing the confederacy to Nazi Germany is a complete strawman." |
I guess I shouldn't be suprised HUR doesn't know what a strawman is.
Quote : | "Honestly if the goal is to improve race relations and decrease racism..." |
*That's* a strawman dummy.
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 12:33 PM. Reason : Dude can't even engineer a google search]6/25/2015 12:31:23 PM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
HUR is a fucking moron and I refuse to respond to his moronic racist bullshit. Suck my black dick HUR
] 6/25/2015 12:32:38 PM |
Bullet All American 28263 Posts user info edit post |
Does anyone post on WRAL stories? If so, someone should respond to the guy defending the crazy Rocky Mount racist and tell him that it DOES appear that he added more flags recently, and that he DOES actually bother people, as evident by an earlier picture of his property, and his rap sheet that includes assault with a deadly weapon
http://www.thesmokinggun.com/documents/stupid/man-corners-market-on-confederate-flag-897435
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 12:40 PM. Reason : ] 6/25/2015 12:40:03 PM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
Lol looks like a bad photoshop.
Quote : | "This guy is crazier than a shithouse mouse." |
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 12:41 PM. Reason : ,]6/25/2015 12:41:12 PM |
HUR All American 17732 Posts user info edit post |
http://money.cnn.com/2015/06/25/technology/apple-pulls-civil-war-games/index.html?iid=hp-stack-dom
wow apple is banning historical civil war games because they contain the confederate flag which could be considered offensive.
What's next banning WW2 games unless the swastika is replaced with a smiley face flag. 6/25/2015 1:00:24 PM |
BlackDog All American 15654 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "I accept the fact that many individuals choose to see the Confederate battle flag as a symbol of racism and divisiveness and I tend not to get too hot and bothered about it. What does bother me however is the movement afoot as of late to draw some sort of moral equivalence between the average Confederate soldier during the Civil War and Nazis. The Southern Armies, a few exceptions aside, largely conducted themselves in a professional, honorable and relatively restrained manner as far as civil wars go. The vast majority of men who fought under the confederate battle flag were simple honest men of modest backgrounds fighting for their state which they saw as their true country and homeland and ultimately for their fellow comrades. Regardless of what liberals would like to believe these men were not the moral equivalent of Totenkopfverbande SS running around summarily executing people they deemed to be undesirables. Furthermore I very much doubt that the average Civil War era white soldier on either side thought of themselves as fighting for or against the institution of slavery. I'd venture to guess that Union or Confederate the average Civil War era fighting man probably had very similar viewpoints on the issue of race" |
Also, who gives a fuck what Apple does? Apple will remove games, but they won't drug test their employees... I applied to work at the data center in Maiden, NC and it is the only IT job I have ever gone for that required no drug test. We despise the flag, but we love heroin!!!
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 1:04 PM. Reason : _]6/25/2015 1:02:44 PM |
Bullet All American 28263 Posts user info edit post |
are lots of people comparing confederate soldiers to nazis?
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 1:05 PM. Reason : ^^that's pretty stupid] 6/25/2015 1:04:25 PM |
BlackDog All American 15654 Posts user info edit post |
It is the most popular thing to do in "picture wars" right now. Basically for the retarded people out there you somehow correlate the confederate flag with nazi symbols and that obviously means the confederate flag is also evil.
It is the distributive property at work. 6/25/2015 1:07:18 PM |
synapse play so hard 60929 Posts user info edit post |
Naw they're both evvvvvil on their own b. 6/25/2015 1:15:14 PM |
BlackDog All American 15654 Posts user info edit post |
I rest my case. 6/25/2015 1:20:08 PM |
synapse play so hard 60929 Posts user info edit post |
You really do need to go back to school. 6/25/2015 1:34:08 PM |
Bullet All American 28263 Posts user info edit post |
Dude raised a gun at an officer and somehow wasn't shot
http://www.wral.com/rocky-mount-man-charged-with-assault-with-a-deadly-weapon/7462499/ 6/25/2015 1:45:36 PM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
cough whitey cough 6/25/2015 1:54:42 PM |
Bullet All American 28263 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Lol looks like a bad photoshop." |
you can actually look at it on google maps now, there's only a few flags on it. and what appears to be electrified wires around the outside of the fence.6/25/2015 1:54:56 PM |
Bullet All American 28263 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Lol looks like a bad photoshop." |
you can actually look at it on google maps now, there's only a few flags on it. and what appears to be electrified wires around the outside of the fence. (arrington st, near the betz st. intersection)6/25/2015 1:55:32 PM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "are lots of people comparing confederate soldiers to nazis?" |
Yes, Blacks feel the same way about confederates as jews and nazis.
It's sad, people see the Nazi flag as hatred and confederate as heritage.
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 1:59 PM. Reason : ,]6/25/2015 1:57:29 PM |
HUR All American 17732 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Yes, Blacks feel the same way about confederates as jews and nazis." |
The two aren't even comparable from a evil or humanitarian aspect. Let's not forget that slavery was legal under the flag of the US and i'm sure there were plenty of slave vessels that flew the US flag while returning from Africa.
[Edited on June 25, 2015 at 2:20 PM. Reason : a]6/25/2015 2:18:53 PM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
HUR is a fucking moron and I refuse to respond to his moronic racist bullshit. Suck my black dick HUR
6/25/2015 2:21:01 PM |
afripino All American 11375 Posts user info edit post |
I'm pretty sure the extermination of the jews was considered legal under the gov't of the Nazis. LOL 6/25/2015 2:24:14 PM |
jbrick83 All American 23447 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Let's not forget that slavery was legal under the flag of the US" |
I'm sorry that didn't work out for you HUR6/25/2015 2:25:41 PM |
Bullet All American 28263 Posts user info edit post |
I mean, the imprisonment and killing of jews was institutionalized by the nazis.... 6/25/2015 2:32:47 PM |
cptinsano All American 11993 Posts user info edit post |
There are a few flags I'd like to ostracize for aesthetics alone. Fuck you Sicily. 6/25/2015 2:48:38 PM |
HUR All American 17732 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "HUR is a fucking moron and I refuse to respond to his moronic racist bullshit. Suck my black dick HUR" |
I bet you personify the stereotypical racist black person that hates whites because their ancestors were slaves and think you are owed reparations6/25/2015 2:49:08 PM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
HUR is a fucking moron and I refuse to respond to his moronic racist bullshit. Suck my black dick HUR
6/25/2015 2:53:11 PM |
synapse play so hard 60929 Posts user info edit post |
except you keep responding to his respond to his moronic racist bullshit 6/25/2015 2:56:39 PM |
Smath74 All American 93277 Posts user info edit post |
So do I need to throw away my favorite toy car from 1981 now?
6/25/2015 4:22:26 PM |
dmspack oh we back 25420 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Honestly if the goal is to improve race relations and decrease racism I think banning flying of the flag would be counter-productive in actually breeding hostility." |
nobody's really talking about banning the flag. it's more like - hey maybe don't fly it on state grounds. and also if private organizations (nascar, for example) want to distance themselves from a flag that many find offensive then that also seems like a good business idea. nobody is saying you, an individual, are banned from having this flag.6/25/2015 5:08:17 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148222 Posts user info edit post |
In NASCAR's case, they might consider adding more flags. They tried to appeal to mainstream liberal America instead of their original country redneck base and in the process they didn't gain many new fans, and lost some of the originals. The confederate flag is exactly what NASCAR needs. 6/25/2015 5:11:47 PM |
BlackDog All American 15654 Posts user info edit post |
^^ this is like supporting Bruce Jenner, you either do it or you will be ostracized. 6/25/2015 8:22:59 PM |
BlackJesus Suspended 13089 Posts user info edit post |
^^Trust me, NASCAR's real problem is its core audience can no longer afford to go to the races. 6/25/2015 8:27:06 PM |
dmspack oh we back 25420 Posts user info edit post |
^^Yeah I don't disagree with you. I'm just kinda at people saying the Confederate flag is being "banned". I realize that's kinda arguing over semantics. 6/25/2015 8:30:03 PM |