http://www.collegefootballnews.com/2006/Features/HistoricalDebate_QB_RC.htm

I think they do this every year because I remember seeing it before but I guess they update it... they go through and rank each school at each position for their entire history. Who is the best RB school, best WR school etc. They do it two different ways, one just looks at college production, and the other looks at both college and pro. Here are the top 5 for the second one:

QB:
Miami
BYU - bullshit
USC
Washington - more bullshit
Michigan

RB:
Ohio State
USC - would have them #1 probably
Penn State
Auburn
Miami

WR:
Florida
Tennessee
USC
Miami
Michigan

TE:
ND
Miami
Michigan
BYU
Penn State

OL:
USC
Michigan
Nebraska
Ohio State
Penn State

4/17/2006 12:49:35 AM

^have you heard of Jim McMahon, Ty Detmer, Steve Young? BYU used to be known as Quarterback U.

4/17/2006 1:02:35 AM

i remember one sports site ranked us in the top 10 of WR U's a couple of years ago.

4/17/2006 1:03:02 AM

WR-Florida?? Florida WR's always end up being shit in the NFL

4/17/2006 1:03:47 AM

Quote :

"BYU - bullshit"

explain

4/17/2006 1:07:04 AM

I just think that other schools should be higher if you count college and NFL... BYU was really heavy on the college side because of the wacky conference they were in. I am suprised ND wasnt higher just for Theisman and Montana alone

Purdue too

[Edited on April 17, 2006 at 1:16 AM. Reason : d]

4/17/2006 1:12:05 AM

we'll who do you think should be in their place. you really haven't done anything other than say, "bullshit"

and BYU should be where they are based upon Young and McMahon solely (using your logic).

4/17/2006 1:16:08 AM

No, thats not using my logic... Montana and Theisman did better when combining college and pro than Young and McMahon did when combining college and pro.


For QB I would have

Miami
Purdue
ND
USC
Michigan

4/17/2006 1:19:45 AM

Both Young and McMahon have super bowl rings and were consitantly at the top of their class. What about Ty Detmer too? Man won a national Championship in Football.

^you also lose all credibility with Purdue at number 2

[Edited on April 17, 2006 at 1:44 AM. Reason : 37000]

4/17/2006 1:43:30 AM

you cant just disregard the ncaa 3rd leading passer :x

4/17/2006 1:51:40 AM

id rank Michigan higher in WR and I agree with Florida

as for BYU def need to be up that high

4/17/2006 1:59:17 AM

UGA needs to be in there for Running Back. The only explanation is if it was heavily weighted to the last couple years, in which case BYU doesn't belong that high for QB.

4/17/2006 8:16:19 AM

Quote :

"^you also lose all credibility with Purdue at number 2"

you are crazy.


and McMahon was nowhere near as good as Theisman or Montana, he had a few decent years on a really good team (in the NFL), thats all.

4/17/2006 11:53:32 AM

all we care about is banners and titles. you have to remember that byu >

4/17/2006 1:06:27 PM

byu is not bullshit...

but this thread is...

4/17/2006 1:11:18 PM

eat a dick

BYU QB stats are inflated because of their system and the shitty fucking conference they were in... the only one that has done anything in the NFL aside from playing on a really good team is Young

4/17/2006 2:49:20 PM

Penn State is definately a RB school when it comes to the pros. I mean, look at all of those successful pro RBs theyve had, like Ki-Jana Carter.

4/17/2006 2:54:43 PM

^ Larry Johnson is pretty damn successful - albeit in just one season

4/17/2006 3:19:57 PM

Quote :

"QB: Miami BYU USC Norm Chow Washington Michigan"

There, I fixed it.

4/17/2006 4:05:13 PM

hard to believe that michigan isn't on the RB list.

4/17/2006 7:07:33 PM

Quote :

"BYU QB stats are inflated because of their system and the shitty fucking conference they were in... the only one that has done anything in the NFL aside from playing on a really good team is Young"

1984 what?

4/17/2006 7:34:38 PM

what about 1984???

4/17/2006 11:57:55 PM

BYU wins the National Championship

4/18/2006 12:36:24 AM

no shit... but since I said:

Quote :

" in the NFL "

that doesnt apply at all... so what about 1984?

4/18/2006 12:59:44 AM