This guy in my league wants me to trade him Ryan Mathews, but he keeps offering me Jonathan Stewart and (insert garbage player here). What kind of deal would be fair to make here given we are in a 12 team league?

My Team
Brett Favre, Min QB
Joseph Addai, Ind RB
Ryan Mathews, SD RB
Andre Johnson, Hou WR
DeSean Jackson, Phi WR
Tony Gonzalez, Atl TE
Zach Miller, Oak TE
49ers D/ST, SF D/ST
Mason Crosby, GB K
Kevin Kolb, Phi QB
Tim Hightower, Ari RB
Jeremy Maclin, Phi WR
Montario Hardesty, Cle RB
Buccaneers D/ST, TB D/ST
Ahmad Bradshaw, NYG RB
Danny Amendola, StL WR

His Team
Jay Cutler, Chi QB
Frank Gore, SF RB
Jonathan Stewart, Car RB
Miles Austin, Dal WR
Reggie Wayne, Ind WR
Jermichael Finley, GB TE P
Jahvid Best, Det RB
Chargers D/ST,
Rob Bironas, Ten K
LaDainian Tomlinson, NYJ RB
T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Sea WR
Chester Taylor, Chi RB
Chad Henne, Mia QB
Bengals D/ST, Cin D/ST
Mike Williams, TB WR
Josh Cribbs, Cle WR

9/2/2010 8:20:45 PM

message_topic.aspx?topic=598511

unless I can get Gore or Wayne, I'm not moving my 2nd best player

9/2/2010 8:22:06 PM

Lawd have mercy.

9/2/2010 8:22:15 PM

Theres not a thread for this.

not at all, and it is definitely not on the first page.

however, Matthews for Gore and Williams or Gore and Best

[Edited on September 2, 2010 at 8:23 PM. Reason : g]

9/2/2010 8:22:36 PM

sorry, eyes seemed to have just jumped over the line that topic was on.


I wouldn't mind getting a hold of Wayne because I would just turn around and trade him to someone else for a better RB, but I would like to get Best.

[Edited on September 2, 2010 at 8:26 PM. Reason : ]

[Edited on September 2, 2010 at 8:26 PM. Reason : and i don't think he is going to go for that]

9/2/2010 8:23:34 PM

Quote :

"however, Matthews for Gore and Williams or Gore and Best"

who in their right mind would trade a 1st round running back for a 3rd round running back, much less a 1st round running back AND another starting running back?

9/3/2010 9:04:10 AM

Personally i wouldn't trade him at all, I think Matthews is going to have a good year, but if you wanted to counter offer, Matthews and Hightower for Stewart and Best wouldn't be a bad trade

9/3/2010 9:53:55 AM